NAIA All-America

1986	Tom Conroy	Honorable Mention
1988	Mike Connor	Third Team
1994	Scott Bittner	Honorable Mention

 
NABC NCAA Division II All-America

1997	Dan Sancomb	Honorable Mention
1998	Dan Sancomb	First Team
2016	Eric Siefert	First Team
2018	Haywood Highsmith	First Team

 
D2CCA All-America

2016	Eric Siefert	First Team
2018	Haywood Highsmith	First Team

 

NABC All-District

2016	Eric Siefert	First Team
2018	Haywood Highsmith	First Team
2024	Marcus Johnson	Second Team

 

D2CCA All-Region

2016	Eric Siefert	First Team
2018	Haywood Highsmith	First Team
2024	Marcus Johnson	Second Team

 

D2CCA Ron Lenz National Player of the Year

2018	Haywood Highsmith

D2CCA Atlantic Region Player of the Year

2018	Haywood Highsmith

 
 
NABC Atlantic Region Coach of the Year

2016	Danny Sancomb

 
 
NAIA Area VII Coach of the Year

1989	Jay DeFruscio

 
MEC Player of the Year

2018	Haywood Highsmith

 
 
MEC Freshman of the Year

2015

Pat Moseh

 
 
WVIAC Freshman of the Year

2009	Cedric Harris

 
 
WVIAC Coach of the Year

1983	Jim O'Brien
1989	Jay DeFruscio
2002	Jay DeFruscio

 
MEC Coach of the Year

2016	Danny Sancomb

 
WVIAC Tournament MVP

2005	Terrance Bradley

 
MEC Tournament MVP

2018	Haywood Highsmith

 
 
MEC Sportsmanship Award

2016

Kyle Ritz

 
 
Academic Awards

1988	Mike Connor	Academic All-America
1989	Mike Connor	Academic All-America
	Doug Kepreos	Academic All-America
2022	Jordan Reid	NABC Honors Court
	Dozie Enyosiobi	NABC Honors Court
	Jay Gentry	NABC Honors Court
	Alex Humphreys	NABC Honors Court
	John Korte	NABC Honors Court
2023	John Korte	NABC Honors Court
	Dozie Enyosiobi	NABC Honors Court
2024	Team Academic Excellence Award	NABC Honors Court
	Dozie Enyosiobi	NABC Honors Court
	Marcus Johnson	NABC Honors Court
	William Gabbert	NABC Honors Court

 
 
All-Conference Awards
West Virginia Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (WVIAC)

YEAR	NAME	AWARD
1961	Tom Santer	First Team
1967	Jim DiPiero	First Team
1968	Jed O’Connell	First Team
1969	Jed O’Connell	First Team
1976	James Kelly	First Team
	Mike Barnes	Honorable Mention
	Rodney Gaddy	Particular Honorable Mention
1977	Rodney Gaddy	First Team
1978	Ed Graham	Particular Honorable Mention
1979	Ron Ferguson	Honorable Mention
	Paul Renowicz	Honorable Mention
1980	Phil Lewton	Special Honorable Mention
	Ron Ferguson	Honorable Mention
	Ed Lastee	Honorable Mention
1981	Ed Lastee	Second Team
	Phil Lewton	Honorable Mention
1982	Jeff Kepreos	Honorable Mention
1983	Jeff Kepreos	Honorable Mention
1984	Jeff Kepreos	Second Team
	Tom Conroy	Second Team
1985	Tom Conroy	Second Team
	Paul McIntyre	Honorable Mention
1986	Tom Conroy	First Team
	Bryant Houston	Second Team
	Paul McIntyre	Honorable Mention
1987	Bryant Houston	First Team
1988	Mike Connor	First Team
	Dave Foose	Special Honorable Mention
	Shawn Straughn	Honorable Mention
1989	Mike Connor	First Team
	Dave Foose	First Team
	Shawn Straughn	Second Team
	Jim Brandt	Honorable Mention
1990	Shawn Straughn	First Team
	Jim Brandt	Honorable Mention
1991	Dave Ealy	First Team
	John Boswell	Second Team
1992	John Beckett	Special Honorable Mention
	Mark Downey	Special Honorable Mention
1993	John Beckett	First Team
	Scott Bittner	Special Honorable Mention
	Mike Gerrasch	Special Honorable Mention
	John Reasbeck	Honorable Mention
1994	Scott Bittner	First Team
	Trey McDonald	Honorable Mention
1995	Scott Bittner	First Team
	Mike Gerrasch	Honorable Mention
	John Reasbeck	Honorable Mention
1996	Mike Gerrasch	Honorable Mention
1997	Dan Sancomb	First Team
	Carlos Turner	First Team
	Mark Mulroy	Honorable Mention
1998	Dan Sancomb	First Team
1999	Jimmy Little	Second Team
2001	Mike Patrick	All-Freshman Team
2002	James Watts	Second Team
	Reggie Moore	Honorable Mention
	Jose Gonzales	All-Freshman Team
2004	Terrance Bradley	Second Team
	Mike Patrick	Honorable Mention
2006	Terrance Bradley	First Team
2007	Ricky Yahn	First Team
2009	Cedric Harris	Second Team All-Freshman Team
2010	Steve Catich	Second Team
	Recardo Gaddy	All-Freshman Team
2011	Steve Catich	Second Team
	Brad Bupont	All-Freshman Team
2012	Steve Catich	First Team
	Ben Siefert	Second Team
2013	Ben Siefert	First Team
	Justin Fritts	All-Freshman Team

 
Mountain East Conference (MEC)
 

2014	Eric Siefert	First Team
	Justin Fritts	Honorable Mention
2015	Eric Siefert	First Team
	Justin Fritts	Second Team
2016	Eric Siefert	First Team
	Haywood Highsmith	First Team
	Justin Fritts	Second Team
2017	Pat Moseh	First Team
	Haywood Highsmith	Second Team
2018	Haywood Highsmith	First Team
	Preston Boswell	Second Team
2020	Jordan Reid	Second Team
2021	Jordan Reid	Second Team
2022	Jarett Haines	Second Team
	Jordan Reid	Second Team
2023	John Korte	First Team
2024	Marcus Johnson	First Team

 
All-Tournament Team
 

1964	Howard Korth
1965	Jim DiPiero
1966	Jed O’Connell
1967	Jed O’Connell
1968	Jed O’Connell
1977	Rodney Gaddy
1978	Ed Graham
	Paul Mulholland
1980	Phil Lewton
1983	Tom Conroy
	Terry McCormick
1986	Tom Conroy
1989	Dave Foose
	Mike Connor
	Shawn Straughn
1990	Shawn Straughn
1992	John Beckett
	Scott Bittner
1994	Scott Bittner
	Trey McDonald
1995	Scott Bittner
1997	Carlos Turner
2000	James Watts
2005	Ricky Yahn
	Jose Gonzalez
2006	Terrence Bradley
2015	Pat Moseh
2016	Haywood Highsmith
2017	Haywood Highsmith
2018	Brent Pregram
	Haywood Highsmith
	Preston Boswell
2022	Jordan Reid

 
 
OTHER WVIAC TOURNAMENT AWARDS

1980	Paul Mulholland	Tournament “Sportsmanship” Award
1983	Tom Conroy	Tournament “Heart & Hustle” Award
	Terry McCormick	Tournament “Sportsmanship” Award
1986	Terry McCormick	Tournament “Heart & Hustle” Award
	Terry McCormick	Tournament “Sportsmanship” Award
1987	Mike Connor	Tournament “First Round Player” Award
1994	Scott Bittner	Tournament “Heart & Hustle” Award